An empty park bench beside a neighborhood sidewalk and leaf-strewn lawn, with modest Petoskey-area homes and bare trees in the background.

Why a Petoskey Buyer's Tax Bill Won't Match the Seller's, and Who Gets the Difference

The property tax figure on a Petoskey listing shows what the current owner paid under a taxable value that has been capped, in many cases for years. The city's finance office says a home sale may lead to an uncapping of taxable value, which can increase property taxes for the new owner. The city's finance FAQ also describes how uncapping affects millage rates.

Taxable value, principal residence status and a property's jurisdiction all feature in Petoskey-area property taxes. The City of Petoskey, Bear Creek Township and Resort Township are all in the Petoskey Public Schools district, and they tax quite differently.

Taxable value and home sales

Under Proposal A, a home's taxable value can rise each year by no more than 5 percent or the rate of inflation, whichever is lower. For 2026, the State Tax Commission set that inflation limit at 1.027, or 2.7 percent, in Bulletin 14 of 2025. A long-held house in a market where values have outrun inflation ends up with a taxable value well below what the market would pay for it.

The Michigan Department of Treasury explains that a transfer of ownership makes taxable value uncap "in the calendar year following the year of the transfer of ownership." State law also lists certain transfers that do not count as a transfer of ownership for this purpose. The city's finance office describes the effect plainly: when a home sells, taxable value "may 'uncap' and reset closer to market value, which can increase property taxes for the new owner."

Where the buyer's extra money goes

The City of Petoskey's finance FAQ says a home sale does not increase the city's revenue, and explains why:

"Under the Headlee Amendment, local governments must reduce millage rates when the overall tax base increases beyond allowable limits. This means that while a new homeowner may pay more due to uncapping, the increased taxable value helps reduce the overall millage rate for other taxpayers."

The same page says the city "generally does not receive a net increase in property tax revenue from the sale of an existing home." As a group, buyers pay more, and the rate for everyone else goes down.

The published rates show that pattern. From 2025 to 2026, the total millage with a Principal Residence Exemption, or PRE, fell slightly in all three jurisdictions of the Petoskey school district.

Jurisdiction 2025 total, PRE 2026 total, PRE Change
City of Petoskey 33.6331 33.2724 down 0.3607
Bear Creek Township 24.3464 24.1877 down 0.1587
Resort Township 22.9559 22.8316 down 0.1243

The 2025 figures come from Treasury's 2025 Total Property Tax Rates report, and the 2026 figures from Emmet County's 2026 millage sheet. A long-time owner and a buyer can live in neighboring houses of equal value and receive different bills, reflecting differences in taxable value.

One school district, three different bills

The address also matters, apart from the reset. Here is Emmet County's 2026 sheet for the three jurisdictions in the Petoskey Public Schools district:

2026 Summer, PRE Summer, non-PRE Winter, PRE Winter, non-PRE Admin fee Annual, PRE Annual, non-PRE
City of Petoskey 25.2181 43.2181 8.0543 8.0543 0% 33.2724 51.2724
Bear Creek Township 10.8500 10.8500 13.3377 31.3377 1% 24.1877 42.1877
Resort Township 10.8500 10.8500 11.9816 29.9816 0% 22.8316 40.8316

A mill is $1 for every $1,000 of taxable value. In the annual totals, the gap between PRE and non-PRE is exactly 18 mills. Treasury's PRE background page explains that this is the local school operating levy, which a principal residence is exempt from, up to 18 mills.

The table also shows which bill those 18 mills appear on. In the city, they are on the July summer bill. In Bear Creek and Resort, they are on the December winter bill.

A school operating proposal through 2034

On May 5, 2026, voters approved the Public Schools of Petoskey operating proposal 2,348 to 1,264. According to the official sample ballot, the proposal covers 2027 through 2034. It caps the non-homestead levy at 18 mills, with up to 3 more mills available to restore reductions made under Headlee.

A sinking fund proposal also passed that day, 2,223 to 1,388. It renewed 1.3914 mills and added 0.1086 mill, for a total of 1.5 mills over the same 2027 to 2034 period. The year-to-year trend has been small rate decreases. This added fraction of a mill pushes the other way for every property in the district, whether in the city or a township.

What the city's extra mills pay for

Part of the gap between the city and the townships is visible in the street. The City of Petoskey levies four millages of its own: 6.8650 mills for general operating, 3.5350 for right-of-way, 1.6229 for the library and 0.4890 for solid waste. The city charter allows up to 5 mills for right-of-way. That money is limited to work inside street rights-of-way: streets, sidewalks, trees, water, sewer and electric. State gas tax money is not enough for the city's street funds, so the Right-of-Way Fund covers the shortfall.

The next large job is already scheduled. The Petoskey News-Review reported on October 6, 2026 that design and engineering had started on a street reconstruction near the Bay and Rose Street intersection, the first of the city's 2027 capital projects. The city's capital improvement listing budgets $1.65 million in 2027 from street funds. The project covers Bay Street from Division to Clinton, Rose Street from Division to just east of Clinton, Williams Street from Bay to Rose, and Clinton Street from East Lake to Rose. The listing cites poor pavement ratings and aged, undersized sanitary sewer and water mains.

Other entries in the same plan:

  • Standish Avenue, 2027: $745,000 in pavement preservation from Buckley Avenue to the city limits, including a new east-side sidewalk, with LTBB/BIA grant funding listed.
  • Atkins Street, 2027: $355,000 from Howard Street to the city limits.
  • Hill Street, 2028: $500,000 from Kalamazoo Avenue to the high school, including a new north-side sidewalk.
  • 2029 reconstruction: a $1.7 million placeholder. Willis and Winfield avenues, Michigan Street, Elizabeth Street and Waukazoo Avenue are listed as possible candidates.

Buyers comparing a city address with one in Bear Creek or Resort can read this list as part of what the higher city rate pays for. Every city taxpayer contributes to it, through a right-of-way levy that has also been reduced under the same Headlee rollbacks described above.

If you're weighing a Petoskey address, Davis Labelle offers a free consultation.

Let’s Make Your Next Move the Right One

I combine data-driven insight with a practical understanding of lifestyle and land value to help my clients make smart, confident real estate decisions. Whether you’re buying a home, acquiring property, or evaluating an investment, I provide clear guidance, strong negotiation, and steady support from start to finish.

Follow Me on Instagram